rss rss rss

Click Here To Subscribe! It’s FREE

Log In
 *Listed among SA's Top 10 travel blogs*
  • Home
  • About Me
  • Contributors
  • Contact Us
  • Behind The Scenes
  • Johannesburg B&Bs
4846114873_25f4621595_b
Trade Secrets / Mar. 01, 2013 / by Caroline / 10 Comments

Why I hate media tours

James Siddall

JAMES SIDDALL knows “freebie” travel invitations come with a hefty price tag. Free lunch? Don’t make him laugh!

Tell people you’re a travel journalist and the reaction is invariably “lucky bugger” or “want to switch jobs?”  But like most good things, there’s a dark side to it. Travel as a journalist usually comes in the form of press junkets – “freebies” – as most publications lack the resources to send their hacks abroad, let alone in five-star splendour.

Freebie invitations are issued when an airline, tourism board or hotel wants to promote itself. The invitation  lands in the editor’s lap. If egalitarian, the editor will then dispense it to his worthiest staff members in much the same way that Santa dispenses his shiniest presents to the most deserving little boys and girls. Indeed, dispensing these freebies often causes much bitterness among less experienced members of staff.
Older hacks know they come with a price tag, which generally entails having as much of one destination rammed down your throat in as short a time as possible.
So when visiting Mauritius, as I did, you will not be left to laze around the pool or on the beach. Instead, a dozen of you will be crammed into a mini-bus with faulty air-con to see what your hosts fondly imagine are “points of interest” you’re just aching to write about. On my Mauritian sojourn, I got to spend just 20 minutes on the beach, away from my colleagues.
Speaking of colleagues, your little group will be a microcosm of society. In addition to the tour leader – who often plays a parental role– there’s also the bore, the rebel, the merry japester, the flirty floozy, the “asshole of the trip” as my well-seasoned journalist friend Chris Marais puts it, and the drunk who empties his mini-bar fridge in the hope that his hosts will pick up the tab.

The schloop’s business card.

In the same group you’re also likely to find the cynic – who mutters unprintable things not quite under his breath – and the suck-up or schloop.
The last is usually a relative newcomer to freebies, and will be glued to the tour guide’s side, making toadying observations. After visiting Mauritius, the schloop will write a piece called “Magical Mauritius,” replete with terms such as “languorously swaying palms,” “tropical paradise” and “buffets groaning with seafood delights.”
Everyone hates the schloop after a few hours, and even the hosts can look a little hard-pushed accommodating them, especially if they’re not from a publication major enough to warrant a substantial time investment.
Conversely, the rebel is despised by the host or tour guide – and covertly admired by the rest of the group, as they’ll airily announce that they won’t be sticking to the itinerary. Instead of viewing a mind-numbing assortment of old tombs, churches and crafts stores, they will do their own thing which might include sleeping in, drinking cocktails all day on the beach (it’s possible to be a drunk and a rebel) or just taking in the local colour. And should they need background for their articles, there are always websites and brochures, right?

Why PRs make me crazy – Caroline Hurry

I’ve been lucky. Over the years I’ve been hosted on dozens of international trips, usually turning left when entering the aircraft. Many have been ultra-brief affairs in my capacity as a motoring writer, with the host car manufacturers not particularly caring what you do with your spare time once you’ve attended an obligatory press conference or two, and driven the new car.
For instance, the junket we went on to Bangkok was for the launch of a new version of the BMW Seven Series. I have no idea why BMW chose the East as a launching pad for an international contingent of writers. But I was glad they did, and I had ample time to explore the night markets (“Diesel” cargo pants for $5 anyone?), the feely-feely bars (depressingly over-rated) and to lounge by the pool of the Mandarin Oriental (wonderful, especially as the hotel is consistently rated among the best in the world).
Far more fearsome are the trips organised by airlines and tourism authorities where they try to show you the country in five minutes, instead of just handing you a glossy press release and letting you doze by the poolside.
One of the worst I’ve been on was to Turkey. For a start, I emerged in Istanbul from a plane reeking of cigarette smoke and eggs, almost blinded with jet lag as only two days before I had been having a magnificent time in Miami with a behemoth of a Lincoln Town Car courtesy of Ford, and my own itinerary. No matter, we were dragged off to an Intercontinental and before I could even unpack, crammed into a minibus taking in “the wonders” of Istanbul. A day later, we were on a series of domestic flights, visiting other parts of Turkey, like Cappadocia, Ephesus and Izmir.
Our group comprised the usual cross-section of characters. I probably occupied neutral ground somewhere between the cynic and the drunk. Anyway, with a few thousand years of history rammed down my throat, I returned home and wrote a six-page story for the national magazine that had sent me. My story began: “I landed in Turkey in a high old state of xenophobia…”
I then went on to cite the Shylockian greed of its merchants and several other points. Of course I added that the place reeked of history, among other positive points but too late, I realised I’d broken the most cardinal rule of freebies: never, ever criticize. Gushing is mandatory.
The tour company leader that had hosted the jaunt got a copy of the magazine and fired off an e-mail to the editor, demanding that the publication be pulled from the shelves since the article was “clearly the work of a young man trying to be funny”.
With more than just a hint of Orwellian overtones, she also offered to show the editor pictures “of James Siddall smiling and having a good time.”
Happily, the editor was less than beguiled with PR types telling him how to run his magazine, and the mag stayed on the shelves. Of course, I never got invited to anything again by that tour company. And when I got around to reading the schloop’s piece called “Terrific Turkey”, I couldn’t believe we’d even been on the same tour  …

Tweet

Written by: Caroline

  • Disillusioned Hack

    This piece rang so many bells for me! Even worse are the PRs who invite a journalist to their client’s venue to come and do a write-up. Then they expect said journalist to pay extra if they’re bringing a partner, even if they’re sharing a room. Or they expect said journalist to fork out for the meals and activities they’re expected to write toadying things about. I speak from experience. PRs: if you’re reading this, you can’t have it both ways, ok …

  • Jemma Jones

    Try going on a really cheap tour and having to share your accommodation with a complete stranger!

  • paul

    A laugh a line Siddall, he made me feel as if i was with him on some of his junkets, experiencing the excruciatingly boring times and the banalaty of being led by a nose ring around a supposedly stunning destination!!

    Being on one of those trips must be like being in class with Spud, we all had the fat kid, the nerd, the jock, the shloop, the effeminate kid, the bully, the brain, the joker, the rebel, the dimbo and especially the arsehole. Being in a minibus with that lot for days on end must be trying, James summed it up so magnificently!!

  • http://www.tillysmith.co.za Tilly

    Hi James
    As a publicist I SO agree – I prefer journalists to experience the facilities as a valued guest, with the exception of meals, accommodation and worthwhile activities and services being offered as complimentary media attractions. However, when the destination is further from our shores and client has to provide transport, it is sometimes more economical to send more than one member of the press. I have a strategy for this but don’t want to give too much of my trade secrets away (I hear my competition is eyeballing this fabulous site)…
    Best
    Tilly

  • Kate

    ah yes, brings back memories of being goose-stepped around hotels in Mauritius, meeting GMs and chefs galore, when all I really wanted was to sink my toes into the “talcum powder beach sand” I’d read about a bajillion times before. but no, each time I got within toe-dipping distance of the beach, I was hustled off on yet another excruciating tour of the suites…

    • Allyson

      My worst is PRs who expect you to sign a contract guaranteeing how much coverage they’re going to get … I always just refuse. Nobody can guarantee that … most of the PRs I know are just full of hot air, never delivering on the promises they make … and as you say, Kate, dragging you around on “site inspections”. When will they learn that relaxed hacks always give better copy? I’ve learnt from years of experience: Just say NO!

  • Well-seasoned Chris Marais

    Actually, Siddall, it’s called Asshole On Tour (AOT). And, sometimes, I’ve been the AOT myself. It’s a kind of roving trophy. 

  • Maplanga

    Most media jollys we have done are filled with rafting the Zambezi, riding elephants and basic site inspections. Some agent famils are filled with endless views of rooms, wheel chair ramps and conference rooms…zzzzz you have to create a healthy balance and know when one room is enough! I do think that the media boys need to suck it in a bit and use the opportunity to inspire and hone their writing skills. We all need each other but if need be media famils can be replaced by agent famils that prove to sometimes be more beneficial to the hotel, lodge or operation.

    • http://twitter.com/Travelwrite1 Caroline Hurry

      Yes, that’s a fair point, Maplanga. Thank you.

  • Christina Pretorius

    Quick solution to all of this – don’t go.


Follow us on twitter

Follow @Travelwrite1

Lethabo Estate

Find us on Facebook

networkedblogs

Follow this blog

Categories

  • Africa
  • Backpacking, Beach & Adventure
  • Books
  • Carolines Blog
  • Columns
  • Contributors
  • Cruises
  • Food
  • Inner Journeys
  • International
  • Most popular
  • News
  • People
  • Ranger Reports
  • Reviews
  • Safari
  • South Africa
  • Specials
  • Trade Secrets
  • Travel Chat
  • Uncategorized

Blogroll

  • Johannesburg Guesthouses
  • Roxanne Reid
  • Zen Haven

Link Partnership

  • All4Women
  • Flights And Frustration
  • Gourmet Guys SA
  • Jessie on a Journey
  • Just The Planet
  • Lethabo Estate
  • SmartTravelInfo

International

Traders hotel

Bite-Sized Singapore

May. 07, 2013 / 0 Comments

GILLIAN MCLAREN does durian ...Read More

A sushi vendor at the Sunday Walking Street. PIcture: Tamara Oberholzer

Charmed by Chiang Mai

Jan. 27, 2013 / 4 Comments

TAMARA OBERHOLSTER and her husband chose Thailand ...Read More

The Islamic Museum in Doha. Picture: Caroline Hurry

Doha Days

Jan. 26, 2013 / 0 Comments

CAROLINE HURRY discovers a brave new world ...Read More

at external6

Explora Atacama

Nov. 20, 2012 / 3 Comments

CAROLINE HURRY reviews Explora Atacama’s Hotel de ...Read More

Sunbathing in the heart of Vienna

Viva Vienna

Oct. 25, 2012 / 0 Comments

SUE ETTMAYR visits the city of her ...Read More

pic3

Jungle Jive

Oct. 18, 2012 / 0 Comments

ROBIN SCHER is led a merry dance ...Read More

A dzong in Bhutan

It’s a no-gho!

Oct. 17, 2012 / 0 Comments

MICHAEL GEBICKI refuses to wear a skirt ...Read More

The author and her boys.

Mad Before, Nomad Now

Aug. 11, 2012 / 2 Comments

MONICA ZWOLSMAN packs up her troubles and ...Read More

LR Colloseum rainbow

No place like Rome

Jun. 27, 2012 / 0 Comments

CAROLINE HURRY finds art and historical ...Read More

berlin brandeber gate

72 Hours in Berlin

Jun. 19, 2012 / 2 Comments

Berlin has a dark past, but the ...Read More

Most popular

luggagenu

Luggage Looting vs Baggage Jacking

May. 16, 2013 / 7 Comments

What’s worse? Getting your luggage lifted or ...Read More

Muti chop. Picture: Michael Sharon

Calling Dr Love

Mar. 30, 2013 / 2 Comments

MAGGIE FOLLETT sheds her clothes and scepticism ...Read More

skykuza

Wild about the fat cats

Jan. 04, 2013 / 2 Comments

STEVIE GODSON finds an armada of ...Read More

One of the roads at Kruger

Kruger Park saak …

Dec. 31, 2012 / 2 Comments

ROBYN VON GEUSAU bemoans the state of ...Read More

hotel horror

Hotel Horrors

Oct. 18, 2012 / 9 Comments

CAROLINE HURRY asks travel journalists and lodge ...Read More

carol

Loo with a view

Jun. 02, 2012 / 8 Comments

CAROL LAZAR's private parts have traveled the ...Read More

Nia illustration low res

O solo mio!

Apr. 14, 2012 / 3 Comments

Nia Magoulianiti-McGregor visits Greece on her ...Read More

DBB Marko's restaurant1

Croatian bites

Apr. 01, 2012 / 1 Comments

Here are DARREL BRISTOW BOVEY’s directions to ...Read More

Karachi: Truck art in all its multicoloured glory. Picture: Janine Lazarus.

Truth or lies?

Feb. 21, 2012 / 5 Comments

JANINE LAZARUS finds peace in Pakistan ...Read More

monica star

Stargazing

Sep. 13, 2011 / 6 Comments

It’s not all it’s cracked up to ...Read More

Recent Comments

  • David Bullard on Seeing stars on the QM2
  • Shelagh on Seeing stars on the QM2
  • Shelagh Foster on Seeing stars on the QM2
  • Elaine Tyrrell on Seeing stars on the QM2
  • Karen Lotter on Hotel Horrors

Recent Posts

  • Aloof in the Kloof
  • Why I love Cape Town
  • Luggage Looting vs Baggage Jacking
  • On the Fly
  • Bite-Sized Singapore

Tags

Air Mauritius Bridget Hilton Barber Cape Town Caroline Hurry Carol Lazar Cayley Christos Charlene Smith Chris Moerdyk Croatia cruising Dave Pusey food Franschhoek Garden Route Gero Lilleike Graham Fiford Gwynne Conlyn Heather Mason Heidi Kingstone Helen Grange James Siddall Janine Lazarus Johannesburg Kruger National Park Kruger Park Lance Cherry Leopard Hills Long Beach Mauritius Michael gebicki Monica Zwolsman Mozambique Nelspruit Peter Davies Rod Baker Ryan Green safari Sandi Caganoff surfing Terry Friend Tilly Smith travel travelwrite Waterberg World Leisure Holidays
  • © Copyright TravelWrite / All Rights Reserved.
  • Wordpress Website Maintenance by AFROmedia